ArbNation Join free

Branch collar and flush cuts: what a 1988 Shigo-cut study and two extension sheets report

A four-year Illinois study found cuts away from the collar left wounds 4 to 6 percent wider than the branch. Iowa State says flush cuts can lead to more internal decay, and Purdue says they leave wounds that invite insects, fungi and disease.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

One journal paper and two extension sheets are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. The paper tests the pruning method Alex Shigo defined and described as natural target pruning. The sheets define the branch collar and branch bark ridge and name the flush cut as a fault.

The 1988 closure study

Dan Neely compared cuts through the branch collar, which he calls conventional, with cuts away from the collar, which he calls Shigo cuts. His paper appeared in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in November 1988. The trees were pin oak, sycamore and Norway maple at the Illinois Natural History Survey arboretum near Urbana. Each year from 1983 to 1986 he took four living branches from each of ten trees per species, two by each method. The branches were 25 to 35 mm across.

Wound closure results in the 1988 study
MeasureConventional cutShigo cut
Wound width above branch diameter32 to 51 percent wider4 to 6 percent wider
Callus growth, first year14.8 mm8.1 mm
Callus growth, second year17.8 mm12.6 mm

After one growing season the exposed wood was about equal on both kinds of wound, even though the conventional cuts started much larger. After the second season more conventional cuts than Shigo cuts were fully closed.

Neely defines the two methods in the paper. Natural target pruning leaves the branch collar on the main stem and removes the rest of the branch. The final cut then follows the angle of the branch bark ridge, which can mean an upstroke with a chain saw where the branch meets the trunk at an acute angle. The conventional cut is a downstroke that begins outside the branch bark ridge and removes some of the collar. He states that it is not a flush cut. He also reports that Shigo warns of chain saw kickback on the final upstroke.

Iowa State on the collar and the flush cut

Iowa State University Extension says to cut just beyond the branch collar and branch bark ridge. It calls the collar the swollen area at the base of the branch, prominent on some trees and hard to see on others. The branch bark ridge is the dark, rough ridge that separates the branch from the main branch or trunk. A change in bark color or texture can mark the collar's position.

Cutting there keeps the tree's natural defenses and supports compartmentalization and callus formation, the answer says. It describes a flush cut as one made as close as possible to the trunk or main branch, and says it destroys those defenses and can lead to more internal decay.

Purdue on removing a branch

Purdue Extension defines the branch collar as the area just below the junction where two branches meet, where stem wood and branch wood intersect. It defines the flush cut as removal of a branch inside the collar, leaving a large wound that invites insects, fungi and disease. Its sheet describes a three-cut method for removing a branch, ending with a final cut just outside the collar. It says a stub left on the tree cannot be walled off and becomes an entry point. Purdue also lists wound paint among improper practices, because it creates a moist, dark environment between paint and wound.

Where the sources differ

The 1988 paper measured faster callus growth around the conventional cuts and found them closed more often by the second year. The two extension sheets place the final cut just outside the collar. Neely's conventional cut is not a flush cut, so the paper does not test the flush cut the sheets warn about.

Sources