ArbNation Join free

Bulk density and compaction thresholds by soil texture: Minnesota and USDA Forest Service

Root-restricting bulk density runs from above 1.80 g/cm3 in sands to above 1.47 g/cm3 in clays, in the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's table. A 1983 USDA Forest Service report explains why finer soils stop roots at lower densities.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Bulk density is the dry weight of soil in a known volume, in grams per cubic centimeter (g/cm3). Cornell's Soil Health Lab fact sheet calls it an indicator of soil compaction: a compacted soil holds more particles in the same volume. Organic matter lowers it, because low-density organic material replaces some of the mineral particles. One g/cm3 equals 62.4 pounds per cubic foot.

Minnesota Pollution Control Agency table

The Minnesota Stormwater Manual prints a table of the relationship of bulk density to root growth by soil texture, in g/cm3. No source is cited for the table.

TextureIdealMay affectRestricts
Sands, loamy sandsunder 1.601.69over 1.80
Sandy loams, loamsunder 1.401.63over 1.80
Sandy clay loams, loams, clay loamsunder 1.401.60over 1.75
Silts, silt loamsunder 1.301.60over 1.75
Silt loams, silty clay loamsunder 1.401.55over 1.65
Sandy clays, silty clays, clay loams with 35 to 45 percent clayunder 1.101.49over 1.58
Clays, over 45 percent clayunder 1.101.39over 1.47

The column headings are ideal bulk densities, bulk densities that may affect plant growth, and bulk densities that restrict root growth. The agency adds that compacted soils restrict water and air transport. Cornell's fact sheet carries a figure on the general relationship of bulk density to root growth by texture, taken from a USDA NRCS document.

USDA Forest Service growth-limiting bulk density

Growth-limiting Soil Bulk Densities as Influenced by Soil Texture, by Richard Daddow and Gordon Warrington (report WSDG-TN-00005, January 1983), was written at the Forest Service's Watershed Systems Development Group in Fort Collins, Colorado. It defines growth-limiting bulk density as the level where resistance to root penetration is so high that root growth essentially stops. Texture is the main property setting it, because fine particles give smaller pores. A silt loam in one cited study had 19 percent macropore space and a penetration resistance of 2.5 bars at 1.4 g/cm3. A sandy loam had 28.9 percent and 1.2 bars at the same density. Another study stopped sunflower roots at 1.75 g/cm3 in sandy soils and 1.46 to 1.63 in clayey soils.

Soil in the report's data tablePlantLimiting density
Nutley clayPea1.37
Colo clayCorn1.30
Nixon silt loamPitch pine, Austrian pine, Norway spruce1.40
Lakewood sandy loamPitch pine, Austrian pine, Norway spruce1.60 to 1.80
Miles loamy fine sandCotton1.82

The authors fitted a line through 21 soil textures to map the limit across the whole texture triangle. Their worked example, a clay loam with 30 percent sand, 34 percent silt and 36 percent clay, comes to about 1.50 g/cm3. The Minnesota table puts clay loams with 35 to 45 percent clay at over 1.58, so the two figures differ.

The report lists its limits. The values hold for soils under 3 percent organic matter and under 10 percent coarse fragments, with particle density near 2.65 g/cm3, and for water content near field capacity. It treats a clay at 1.40 g/cm3 as close to its threshold and a sandy soil at the same density as probably unaffected. It also reports studies where small density increases cut root growth well below the limit.

Sources