ArbNation Join free

Climbing irons in history: the tradition of spurs and the first calls to restrict them

One ISA history traces spurs to telegraph linemen and quotes an 1881 pruning treatise that already called for restricting them. Codes from the UK, New South Wales and New Zealand cover them today.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

What the named histories and codes publish about climbing irons is described here. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Origins and the 1881 warning

Donald F. Blair, a consulting arborist, gave the ISA a history talk at its 90th Annual Meeting in Milwaukee in 2014. He says spurs were first invented for linemen installing telegraph lines on poles. He puts the first institutional need for line clearance tree work probably with the invention of the telegraph in 1837, and a coast-to-coast telegraph system to 1861. By his count spurs had been in use for almost 50 years when A. Des Cars wrote his treatise on tree pruning, translated from the French in 1881.

Blair names the Des Cars treatise as the earliest writing directly related to modern arboriculture that he takes up. Blair's quotation is the only source for the Des Cars passage here. The treatise says that the climbing spurs some professional pruners use should not be allowed except in very exceptional cases or on very large trees. It singles out pruners paid by the tree or by the quantity of wood cut. It adds that even good workmen should never use spurs on young trees, because the bark is too thin to resist the wounds from the sharp iron teeth. Those wounds, it says, encourage injurious side shoots on the trunk and leave defects in the wood that never disappear and cut its value.

Blair's own comment is that arborists have warned against spurs since before Des Cars, and that after more than 100 years too many still wear spurs to top trees.

Limits in three codes

The Industry Code of Practice for Arboriculture, Tree Work at Height, second edition of May 2020, covers climbing irons in clause 3.8.7. Spikes or spiking, as the clause calls it, is a technique for ascent, descent and movement where the operator needs a secure, mobile connection with the stem. The clause finds it most useful on featureless vertical or near-vertical stems. Spike use is invasive and can badly damage the tree. The examples of use where tree health is of negligible consequence are a tree or tree section being removed and aerial rescue where the casualty's safety takes priority. Spiking is not a stand-alone technique and must be used with a personal fall protection system.

SafeWork NSW's Tree works code of practice, in force since 27 March 2026, lists climbing spikes under 4.8. The code describes sharpened steel spikes attached to a climber's leg. Their use goes with a fall prevention system of a work positioning harness and adjustable lanyards. The code limits them to trees being removed, not pruning. Wearing them while moving around on the ground is out, because they can puncture legs and feet.

WorkSafe New Zealand's Approved Code of Practice for Safety and Health in Arboriculture, November 2012, defines spikes (spurs, climbing irons) as a climbing accessory attached to the lower leg and used with a safety strop. Its section 3.2.7 requires spurs to be sourced from acknowledged suppliers and used to the manufacturer's specifications. Climbers shall check components for hairline cracks, bent or loose spikes and worn straps before use. The code asks for spurs to be kept sharpened as the manufacturer recommends. The clause says nothing on removals or pruning.

Where the three codes put the limit
CodeClauseLimit on pruning or tree health
UK industry code, 20203.8.7Only where tree health is of negligible consequence, such as a tree being removed or aerial rescue
SafeWork NSW, 20264.8Only if the tree is being removed, not when pruning
WorkSafe New Zealand, 20123.2.7No such limit in the clause; it covers sourcing, checks and sharpening

Sources