Drying defects: checking, honeycomb, collapse and stain, defined by FPL
The US Forest Products Laboratory defines drying defects as flaws that appear as wood dries: checks, honeycomb, collapse, ring failure, warp, wet pockets and stain. Each has a named cause in the FPL kiln manual and Wood Handbook.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The Forest Products Laboratory (FPL) of the US Forest Service defines a drying defect in the Dry Kiln Operator's Manual as any characteristic or blemish in a wood product that occurs during drying and reduces the product's intended value. Drying degrade is the narrower term for a defect that lowers the grade of lumber. Some defects are first noticed after drying, so they get the name even when they started in the tree, the log or the green lumber.
The manual sorts drying defects into four groups: rupture of wood tissue, warp, uneven moisture content and discoloration. The Wood Handbook, FPL's later engineering reference, uses three groups: fracture or distortion, warp, and discoloration. Both name shrinkage as the main cause of ruptures and of distortion, and drying temperature as the most important processing factor.
Defect names and FPL definitions
| Defect | FPL definition | Cause statement |
|---|---|---|
| Surface check | A check starting on a wide-grain surface and extending into the interior of a board | Drying stresses exceed the tensile strength of the wood across the grain. The outer shell of the board is in tension |
| End check | A check starting on an end-grain surface | Moisture moves much faster along the grain than across it, so the ends dry faster than the middle |
| Honeycomb | Checks, often not visible on the surface, in the interior of a piece of wood, usually along the wood rays | A tensile failure across the grain in the core of the board, while the core is still wet and drying temperatures stay too high for too long |
| Collapse | Severe distortion or flattening of single cells or rows of cells during drying, often seen as a caved-in or corrugated surface | Compressive drying stresses inside the board beyond the wood's compressive strength, or liquid tension in water-filled cell cavities |
| Ring failure | A failure parallel to the annual rings, within a growth ring or between two rings | Internal tension stresses, especially in high-temperature drying, after the stress reversal |
| Warp | Any deviation of the face or edge of a board from flatness, or an edge not at right angles to the adjacent face or edge | Differences between radial, tangential and longitudinal shrinkage, or growth stresses |
| Water pocket | An internal pocket or streak with a moisture content 10 percent or more above the board average | A board whose average moisture content is acceptable but whose core is wetter |
| Stain | A discoloration that may be caused by micro-organisms, metal or chemicals | Chemical reactions in the wood, or fungi and bacteria that grow in the sapwood |
Checks and splits
The Dry Kiln Operator's Manual places surface checks in the wood rays on the flatsawn faces of boards. They usually appear early in drying because the surface dries too quickly in air that is too dry. Thick, wide, flatsawn lumber is more susceptible than thin, narrow lumber. Many surface checks in hardwoods close in the later stages, when the shell changes from tension to compression. They can reopen in use as humidity swells and shrinks the surface.
End checks also run in the wood rays. The tendency to end check grows with the thickness and width of the lumber. End splits are often an extension of end checks into the board. The manual adds that end splits are often caused by growth stresses and so are not a drying defect.
Ohio State University Extension defines a check as a defect in which wood fibers separate because of non-uniform drying in the early stages. Its factsheet puts surface checks along the flat faces of a board and end checks on the edge faces. The FPL manual places end checks on end-grain surfaces. Ohio State also describes oak and hickory boards drying faster on the outer shell than in the core in hot, dry July and August weather, which produces checks and casehardening.
Honeycomb, collapse and ring failure
The FPL manual describes honeycomb as an internal crack, and says it may not show on the surface of a planed board until the board is machined into millwork. It can cause heavy volume losses. Severely honeycombed lumber often has a corrugated surface and is often found with severe collapse. The manual also notes that deep surface and end checks that close tightly at the surface but stay open below it are often called honeycomb. They are also known as bottleneck checks.
Ohio State defines honeycomb as checking in the interior of a piece of wood, normally across the annual ring, as a consequence of accelerated initial drying. The Wood Handbook describes it as an internal crack that occurs in the later stages of kiln drying when the board core is in tension.
Collapse shows up in severe cases as grooves or corrugations, a washboarding effect, at thin places in the board. A slight amount is difficult or impossible to detect at board level. Both causes act early in drying, but collapse is not usually visible on the surface until later. The manual links collapse to excessively high dry-bulb temperatures early in kiln drying and names wetwood as particularly susceptible. Collapse is rare in air drying.
The manual describes reconditioning as steaming lumber as near as possible to 212 °F and 100 percent relative humidity, which can remove much of the excess shrinkage and washboarding. It is most effective when the average moisture content is about 15 percent and takes 4 to 8 hours. The manual says the treatment was first used commercially in Australia.
Ring failure is similar in appearance to shake, which is the same kind of failure in the standing tree or at felling. The manual lists three more rupture defects. Boxed-heart splits come from the difference between tangential and radial shrinkage around the pith, and the manual calls them virtually impossible to prevent. Checked knots come from shrinkage differences within the knot. Loose knots form because encased knots are held in place only by bark and pitch, so the dried knot ends up smaller than the knothole.
Warp
The Dry Kiln Operator's Manual names five types of warp: cup, bow, crook, twist and diamonding. The Wood Handbook names six: bow, crook, twist, oval, diamond and cup. Warp is aggravated by irregular or distorted grain and by abnormal wood such as juvenile and reaction wood.
| Type | What it is | Cause statement |
|---|---|---|
| Cup | A deviation flatwise across the width of a board | Greater shrinkage parallel to the growth rings than across them. Flatsawn boards cup toward the face closest to the bark. Quartersawn boards do not cup |
| Bow | A deviation flatwise along the length, from end to end | Differences in longitudinal shrinkage on opposite faces. It is associated with juvenile wood near the pith, compression or tension wood, and crossgrain |
| Crook | The same as bow, but edgewise | As for bow |
| Twist | The four corners of a face no longer lie in one plane | Spiral, wavy, diagonal, distorted or interlocked grain |
| Diamonding | A square takes a diamond-shaped cross section | Different radial and tangential shrinkage in squares whose growth rings run diagonally from corner to corner |
Moisture content and wet pockets
The manual says kiln operators in the United States aim for a target of 15 percent moisture content for softwood dimension lumber and 6 to 8 percent for lumber going into furniture, flooring or millwork. Softwood dimension lumber at 19 percent or less is graded dry, and lumber at 20 percent and over is unseasoned. Softwood dimension lumber dried below 10 percent is usually considered overdried, and it is subject to planer splits.
Water pockets are internal pockets or streaks that can be pencil thin. They build steam pressure during electronic gluing, enough to shatter the surface of the piece. Dielectric moisture meters read wrongly in wood that holds them.
Stain and discoloration
The Wood Handbook splits discoloration into chemical, which is non-microbial, and fungal, which is microbial. Chemical stain comes from oxidative and enzymatic reactions with compounds in the wood. It ranges from pinkish, bluish and yellowish hues through gray and reddish-brown to dark brown. The Handbook ties brown stain in pines and darkening in many hardwoods to drying temperatures that are too high.
Blue stain is the most common fungal stain. Blue-stain fungi do not cause decay of the sapwood, and they do not usually grow in heartwood, which lacks their food. The Handbook says blue stain, which is not a mold, can develop if initial drying is too slow. It occurs often in summer when lumber is exposed to air before kiln drying.
The kiln manual separates two marks left by stickers, the strips between layers of boards. Sticker stains are imprints darker than the wood between the stickers. Sticker marks are lighter than the exposed board surface. Both are much more common in sapwood than in heartwood, and their causes can be chemical, microbial or both.
Casehardening is a related stress condition. The manual defines it as a condition of stress and set in which the outer fibers are in compression and the inner fibers in tension, and the stresses persist when the wood is uniformly dry. Reverse casehardening is the opposite pattern, produced by overconditioning.
Sources
- US Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, Dry Kiln Operator's Manual (Agriculture Handbook 188), W. T. Simpson, 1991, chapter 8 and glossary, read October 16, 2026
- US Forest Service Research and Development, Treesearch record for the Dry Kiln Operator's Manual, read October 16, 2026
- US Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook (FPL-GTR-282, 2021), chapter 13, Drying and Control of Moisture Content and Dimensional Changes, read October 16, 2026
- US Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook (FPL-GTR-282, 2021), full volume with glossary, read October 16, 2026
- Ohio State University Extension, An Overview of Drying Hardwood Lumber (factsheet F-73), January 20, 2012, read October 16, 2026