Knot strength loss in rope: the NZ code, the ICoP and Kane's 2012 hitch tests
The New Zealand code says knots can weaken a rope by up to 50 percent of its breaking strength. The ICoP rates a new rope at 15 kN with a termination and 22 kN without. Kane's 2012 tests used rigging hitches, not climbing lines.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.
Credits: SafeWork NSW text is adapted from the Tree works code of practice (March 2026), copyright State of New South Wales (SafeWork NSW), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0; changes were made, because the text is summarised and reworded. WorkSafe New Zealand material is summarised from its Approved Code of Practice for Safety and Health in Arboriculture (November 2012), with the source acknowledged.
The New Zealand code
The WorkSafe New Zealand Approved Code of Practice, section 3.2.4, says knots can weaken a rope by up to 50 percent of its breaking strength. The same passage puts the safe working load of a climbing rope and equipment at 10 percent of the breaking or tensile strength of the rope.
Climbing lines are built with a breaking strain of 22 kN when new and are free of joining splices or knots. Where appropriate, a knot is placed at the end of the line as a back-up to prevent the climber descending off the end. Section 3.2.1 gives the tying rule as tie, dress, set. Friction hitches use cordage of at least 70 percent of the diameter of the climbing line.
The ICoP
The ICoP, 3.10.6.8, sets the minimum breaking strength of a new rope at 15 kN with a termination and 22 kN without one. Its glossary says a termination can be a knot, a splice, a stitched eye or a combination. Splices are formed only by the manufacturer, or with its consent against validated performance criteria.
In section 3.3.5.3, rigging operators must be able to understand strength loss due to knots within cordage components. The ICoP gives no percentage for that loss.
Kane's 2012 tests
Kane's paper in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, January 2012, measured the breaking load of four hitches tied in seven ropes. The hitches were the clove hitch, the cow hitch, the running bowline and the timber hitch. They were tied around a utility pole 20 cm in diameter and pulled in a tensile testing machine at 6.5 mm/s.
The paper is about rigging slings and rigging ropes, and the load was applied statically. It does not test climbing lines or climbing hitches. Kane writes that static results cannot easily be applied to dynamic loads.
Breaking load was similar among the hitches and varied widely among the ropes. The mean for each hitch fell between 28.27 and 29.72 kN. The means for the seven ropes ran from 21.58 to 38.16 kN, and the rope explained 88 percent of the variance. The rope failed at the same place in every test: the first bend in the standing part, where it enters the hitch and cinches around the pole.
Kane did not calculate efficiency, the knotted strength as a share of unknotted strength. He did not have the unknotted breaking loads for the ropes tested. The table sets the makers' rated breaking loads from the paper beside the knotted means.
| Ropes of 12.7 mm | Rated breaking load, kN | Mean breaking load tied in hitches, kN |
|---|---|---|
| Single braid, four ropes | 26.69 to 32.47 | 21.58 to 27.89 |
| Double braid, three ropes | 44.04 to 48.04 | 31.06 to 38.16 |
Knot wording in other codes
The SafeWork NSW code asks that knots be tied, dressed and pre-loaded before the climber leaves the ground. It lists knots that are insecure if tied wrongly, need a second knot for security, or creep or loosen under load, and gives the stopper knot and barrel knot as examples.
WorkSafeBC Part 26, 26.12.0.4, requires the arborist to tie a stopper knot at the end of each climbing line. The two texts differ: the NSW code lists the stopper knot among knots that creep or loosen, and the British Columbia rule requires one.
Sources
- WorkSafe New Zealand, Approved Code of Practice for Safety and Health in Arboriculture, November 2012, sections 3.2.1 to 3.2.5, read October 19, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Industry Code of Practice for Arboriculture: Tree Work at Height (ICoP), second edition, May 2020, sections 3.3.5.3 and 3.10.6.8, read October 19, 2026
- Kane, B., Breaking Load of Hitches and Ropes Used in Rigging, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 38(1), January 2012, pages 1 to 5, read October 19, 2026
- SafeWork NSW, Tree works code of practice, commenced March 27, 2026, sections 4.1 and 4.9, read October 19, 2026
- WorkSafeBC, OHS Regulation Part 26 Forestry operations and similar activities, section 26.12.0.4, read October 19, 2026