ArbNation Join free

Paving over and near tree roots: cellular confinement, piled rafts and structural soil

The Arboricultural Association's Guidance Note 12 covers cellular confinement sub-bases for surfacing near trees, and Cornell's Urban Horticulture Institute describes a load-bearing structural soil. Both address roots under hard surfaces.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on a news item announcing an Arboricultural Association guidance note and on two Cornell University publications. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Roots under hard surfaces

The Tree Care Supporters news item of November 25, 2020, announces the Association's guidance. Tree roots can be damaged by soil stripping, it states. The volume of viable soil also shrinks when soil is compacted or sealed from above. For these reasons new hard surfacing within root protection areas should be specified only when other alternatives are not feasible.

Cornell's booklet, Using Structural Soil in the Urban Environment (Bassuk, Grabosky and Trowbridge, 2005), names the lack of usable soil volume as the most significant problem for urban trees. Compaction crushes the macropores that carry air and water. Roots that meet dense soil change direction, stop growing or stay abnormally close to the surface. That shallow rooting leaves trees more vulnerable to drought and can cause pavement heaving.

Cellular confinement near trees

The news item says that when no-dig surfacing is required near trees, a cellular confinement sub-base is the most used approach. It names alternatives that may sometimes work better: piled rafts using conventional or screw piles, and stone-filled wire gabions. Above-ground cellular confinement has been used in the UK for over 20 years. Until the Association's Guidance Note 12, The Use of Cellular Confinement Systems near Trees, the only guidance for arboricultural professionals was Arboricultural Practice Note 12, a short guide of 2007.

What Guidance Note 12 sets out, as the news item reports it
TopicPosition
Cell materialHigh-density polyethylene (HDPE) geocells rather than geocells of flexible geotextile
Top dressingThe final top dressing needs to be permeable
Method statementEvery installation needs a project-specific arboricultural method statement
SupervisionGround preparation is strongly recommended under arboricultural supervision
Infill and equipmentSuitable infill materials and equipment are described

The note took three years to complete and included consultation with manufacturers and arboricultural professionals. Its authors tried to avoid being overly prescriptive because each site differs in trees, soil, scale and use.

Structural soil under pavement

Cornell's Urban Horticulture Institute developed a structural soil to bear pavement loads after compaction while still allowing root penetration. It is a two-part system. A rigid lattice of uniformly graded angular crushed stone, 3/4 to 1 1/2 inches, carries the load. A heavy clay loam or loam with a minimum of 20 percent clay and 2 to 5 percent organic matter is suspended between the stones without over-filling the voids.

The booklet gives these uses and depths:

  • It is intended for paved sites, and the booklet names pedestrian mall paving, sidewalks, parking lots and low-use access roads.
  • Depth is at least 24 inches, preferably 36 inches.
  • Cornell research found roots grow deep into the base course, away from temperature swings at the surface, so they are less likely to heave and crack pavement than under conventional paving.
  • Parking-lot tree islands can be enlarged with structural soil under the asphalt. Break-out zones in narrow tree lawns are usually made by removing two 5-foot concrete flags and excavating 24 to 36 inches.

The Cornell outreach page lists a 15-page booklet on porous asphalt over structural soil, which it says lets water and air reach the base course below the pavement surface.

Sources