Research words: peer review, replicate, confidence interval, open data and more
Peer review, confidence interval, replicate and open data turn up in every tree-care paper. Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, the National Library of Medicine and the Royal Society each define the words they use.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Arboriculture & Urban Forestry (AUF) is the International Society of Arboriculture's bimonthly, peer-reviewed journal. It is open access, has run since 1975, and was first called the Journal of Arboriculture. The words below are defined by AUF, the National Library of Medicine and the Royal Society. The guide to reading tree-care research papers puts them to use.
Peer review
AUF bases acceptance on editorial criteria and peer review. Reviewers judge appropriateness of content, contribution, applicability, methodology, and accuracy and clarity of presentation. An Associate Editor reads each manuscript and asks for at least two additional peer reviews.
Reviewers send recommendations to the author. Revision is usually necessary after review, and final acceptance depends on satisfactory revision. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision. A completed Conflict of Interest form must be on file before an accepted manuscript appears.
Article types in AUF
| Term | Meaning at AUF |
|---|---|
| Original article | Original fundamental or applied research. The abstract is structured (Background, Methods, Results, Conclusions) and runs to 250 words at most |
| Review article | A literature review or synthesis of earlier work. It identifies trends, marks areas for new work, or compares competing theories. The abstract is unstructured, up to 250 words |
| Short communication | A report of preliminary or novel results on limited data sets, an analysis of procedures, equipment or management systems, or a new theoretical view |
| Letter to the editor | A response to ideas or facts in the journal, about material published within a year of the letter's submission. Up to 750 words, with no tables or figures. The original authors may reply in the same issue |
| Editorial | A short opinion piece from a leader in the field. Up to 3,000 words and 20 references, with no abstract, tables or figures |
Statistics words
The National Library of Medicine course, Finding and Using Health Statistics, lists p-value, significance level and confidence intervals among its common terms. Its confidence interval page gives the meanings below.
| Term | Meaning in the course |
|---|---|
| Confidence interval | Uses a sample to estimate the interval of probable values for the whole population. It shows the range the true estimate should fall in if the study were redone many times |
| 95% confidence interval | If the study were repeated many times with new samples, the true value would lie inside the calculated interval 95% of the time. The course gives true value 50 with intervals such as 47 to 53, 48 to 54 and 49 to 51 |
| Null value | The value that means no difference, usually zero or one. A result is not statistically significant when the interval includes it |
| Borderline p-value | A p-value equal to the critical p-value. The course says the confidence interval adds information about significance in that case |
| Reliability | The consistency of a measurement, or the ability to repeat it and get the same result. The course uses a scale that gives the same weight for a cup each time |
Replication and open data
The Royal Society makes data, code and research materials public as a condition of publication. It gives the reason in its policy: others can verify and build on the work. Sufficient information and data must be available to replicate all study findings in an article. The policy bars the statement that data are available from the authors on request.
| Term | Meaning in the policy |
|---|---|
| Replicate | The policy asks for enough information and data to replicate all study findings in an article. Theoretical studies that use no data or code may be replicated without them |
| Data accessibility statement | A statement in the manuscript form that says where the supporting data, materials and code can be found. It lists the repository and the DOI of the deposited data |
| Repository | The place where data and code are archived. The Royal Society says the chosen repository should be public, hold data under an open licence (CC0 or CC-BY), give files a DOI, make versioning clear and provide for permanent access |
| DOI | A persistent identifier. The policy asks for the DOI of deposited data and strongly recommends a repository that issues DOIs for code. Datasets must be listed in the reference section, and code is strongly encouraged there |
| Read-me file | A file beside the data and code that describes each file and each column, including units of measurement |
| Embargo | The policy's general rule is that data, code and materials are public at the time of publication. Exceptions are rare and at the journal's discretion |
The policy lists benefits of sharing. Readers and reviewers can replicate studies and find statistical or methodological errors. Others can reuse the data in meta-analyses. Errors found at submission may mean fewer retractions.
Sources
- International Society of Arboriculture, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry (journal page with submission categories and peer review process), read October 21, 2026
- US National Library of Medicine, Finding and Using Health Statistics, Common Terms and Equations: Confidence Intervals, read October 21, 2026
- The Royal Society, Journal policies: Data sharing, read October 21, 2026