ArbNation Join free

Rigging anchors in decayed trees: what the standards and the research say

The UK Industry Code of Practice requires anchors that tree condition cannot compromise. A 2009 study of 13 red pines put the failure point of a rigged trunk at 60 percent hollow when decay is centred and 45 percent when it is offset.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Where the sources sit

SourceWhat it prints on anchors and tree condition
Industry Code of Practice, Tree Work at Height, Edition 2, May 2020Operators must be able to assess tree condition before work and rate the severity of structural defects. They must also select anchor points that tree condition or the work itself cannot compromise, and evaluate their capacity to bear load.
Arboricultural Association Safety Guide 3, Rigging and Dismantling, December 2021A checklist: whether the species is capable of supporting the potential load, whether the selected anchor points are strong enough, and whether the consequences of anchor failure were considered.
Kane, Brena and Autio, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 35(2), March 2009Measured forces at the block and stress in the trunk on 13 red pines, then estimated how much decay a trunk could hold before failing under those stresses.
Arboricultural Association, rule of thumb for rigging forcesReports peak forces at the rigging point from drop tests, acting at an angle to the trunk and creating a lateral bending moment that may cause a stem used as an anchor point to fail.

The code and the checklist

The Industry Code lists tree condition assessment as a duty before work. The assessment looks at the implications for working at height, including a lowering system. It allows for the species and timber characteristics, parts of the tree hidden by ivy or epicormic growth, and structural defects in the tree or in adjoining trees. At the start of work operators confirm tree condition on site and validate what was gathered earlier. Significant changes to tree condition are recorded and passed to the competent person before aerial work starts.

For personal fall protection the code requires that the anchor point be unquestionably reliable and capable of withstanding any foreseeable loading. Safety Guide 3 is a checklist summarised from the Association's Technical Guide 3. Its anchor section asks if the selected anchor is strong enough and if redirects are used so as not to load anchors adversely. A separate item asks if the weight estimate of a section accounts for mass, dimensions, foliage, taper, decay and moisture. That decay item concerns the section being removed, not the anchor.

What the 2009 study measured

Kane, Brena and Autio removed 13 red pines, averaging 30.6 cm in diameter at breast height and 21.6 m tall. The trees were chosen for a lack of structural defects. Each top and four further pieces were rigged with a block and a friction device, and the forces were recorded with dynamometers.

The paper reports that mass of the piece was by far the best predictor of force at the block and tension in the rope. The force at the block was more than double the rope tension, and friction in the block added about 20 percent to twice the tension. Tops and pieces behaved differently, which the authors attribute to greater trunk deflection when a top is removed.

The decay figures were calculated, not measured on decayed trees. The authors reduced the trunk cross-section mathematically until rigging stress equalled the tree's strength. For a concentric decay column, failure came at a cross-section 60 percent hollow. For a column offset to the edge, failure came at 45 percent hollow. The paper calls these values to be taken with extreme caution. Stress was measured only near the base of the tree, and the impact of the piece might cause failure at another point. The authors add that a climber's experience may still be more valuable in judging whether a tree is safe to climb, and that the figures can provide some guidance in assessing the safety of rigging a particular tree.

Forces on the anchor stem

The Arboricultural Association page reports tests from the HSE rigging research, with the friction device blocked. Peak forces did not act parallel to the trunk. They acted on average at 30 to 40 degrees to the trunk axis. The forces at the rigging point exceeded the weight of the lowered section by an average of 8 to 12 times, and the factor falls as mass rises (HSE Rigging Report 2008). The Association's rule of thumb for the worst case is peak force on the pulley of 8 times the trunk mass plus 500 kp, tested on 12 mm and 14 mm double braid and kernmantle ropes. It underestimated peak forces by less than 10 percent in 22 drops.

Where the sources differ

  • The Association page says a force meter placed between the pulley and the anchor sling can mislead, because it lengthens the fall. It names the 2009 study among the work that used this setup. The study itself notes that its dynamometer raised the fall distance compared with a work situation.
  • Neither research source reports a test on a trunk that was actually decayed. The 60 and 45 percent figures come from a calculation on sound pines.

Related pages are forces in rigging and anchor and rigging terms in ANSI Z133.

Sources