ArbNation Join free

Root barriers: what published trials and extension services say

A six-year California trial found circular root barriers nearly eliminated large surface roots within 120 cm of the trunk, but roots grew under them and returned to the surface in favourable soil. New Mexico State extension says roots often get past plastic sheet overlaps.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The facts on this page come from two trials in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry and one New Mexico State University extension column. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Neither trial measured pavement damage. The extension column answers a home owner's question about a patio.

The six-year trial of circular barriers

Dennis Pittenger and Donald Hodel reported their trial in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry in January 2009. It followed American sweetgum and Indian laurel fig at the University of California, Riverside, planted from #5 containers in June 1992. Five treatments were set at planting: no barrier, a commercial circular barrier, two nursery containers with the bottoms removed and a black polyethylene sleeve. The design was 10 replicates of each species and treatment, 100 trees in all.

Six years after installation, the barriers had reduced the total number of roots in the surface 15 cm (6 in) of soil. They nearly eliminated large surface roots, 5 cm (2 in) or more in diameter, within a 120 cm (48 in) radius of the trunk. Low-cost barriers, including a nursery container with the bottom removed, were equally effective at reducing large surface roots.

Roots still grew below the barriers and returned to the surface soil when soil texture, bulk density and water content at the bottom of the barrier were near optimum for root growth. Many small roots, 1.25 to under 2.5 cm (0.5 to under 1 in) across, grew in the upper 15 cm just beyond the barriers, within 18 to 60 cm (7 to 24 in) of the trunk. No barrier treatment reduced small roots of either species beyond 60 cm (24 in).

The authors write that keeping pavement at least 120 cm (48 in) away from trees would be as effective as a root barrier in reducing the possibility of damage from large surface roots. A #15 nursery container used as a barrier reduced the caliper increase of both species.

The vertical barrier trial

E. Thomas Smiley's paper, in the same journal in May 2005, tested vertical barriers on willow oak at the Bartlett Tree Research Lab in Charlotte, North Carolina. Trees were planted on November 8, 2000, with barrier panels 45 cm (18 in) deep set 60 cm (2 ft) from the trunk line. The five barrier types were a polypropylene panel, the same panel with a copper coating, a heavyweight geotextile, a fabric with herbicide-bearing nodules and a copper-coated needle-punched fabric. A sixth group had no barrier.

On February 26, 2002, after two growing seasons, five trees per treatment were excavated. No roots penetrated any barrier. None of the roots examined were over 1.25 cm (0.5 in) across. Some roots had grown beneath the barrier and upward, 15 cm (6 in) outside it. At that plane, control trees had more roots than any other treatment from the surface to 30 cm (12 in) deep, at the P = 0.05 level.

Smiley reports that all five barriers changed the growth patterns of roots that met them. Root growth in the area where a sidewalk would sit was greatly reduced compared with the control trees. He writes that it is too early to speculate on the final disposition of the roots that grow under the barriers.

New Mexico State extension on patios

In an October 2005 column, Marisa Thompson, the university's Extension Horticulture Specialist, lists three methods for keeping roots from a patio. The first is digging a trench along the patio edge each year, which cuts roots before they grow large. For a very vigorous tree the column puts it at twice a year.

The second is a vertical solid barrier of metal, plastic or concrete, set once in a trench. Thick plastic sheet is perhaps the easiest and cheapest, but the overlap between sheets is the weak point, and roots often find their way past it and may cause damage in time. The third is a thin plastic fabric with dots of hard plastic carrying an herbicide, usually trifluralin. It stops root growth at the barrier without killing the tree, takes the least effort, and should give many years of protection.

The column calls a barrier effective in protecting pavement from established trees if the trees are not injured during installation. Trenching too close to the tree can damage major roots, which can damage or kill the tree.

Who to call

Sources