Root pruning near pavement and trunks: what Smiley's trial and extension report
In E. Thomas Smiley's pull tests on young willow oaks, trench cuts made at three trunk diameters or farther caused no significant drop in pulling force. A cut tangential to the trunk cut the pulling force by 35 percent.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Root pruning is described below as a peer-reviewed trial, New Mexico State University Extension and the ISA publish it. It is not training and does not teach the work. Root pruning before a transplant is not covered.
Smiley's willow oak trial
E. Thomas Smiley published Root Pruning and Stability of Young Willow Oak in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in March 2008 (volume 34, issue 2, pages 123 to 128). Thirty willow oaks were planted in November 2000 as 5 cm (2 in) caliper balled-and-burlapped trees. They were pull-tested in January 2007 by pulling the trunk to 1 degree from vertical with a measured force. A third of the trees were also pulled to failure, and the 1 degree force tracked the failure force with an r-squared of 0.76.
The trial simulated two kinds of root loss. Linear cuts across the root zone stood for utility trenching, and single cuts to buttress roots stood for roots lost to decay or repair.
Linear cuts at set distances
A trench 3 m long and 40 cm deep was cut at five times the trunk diameter, then at four, three, two and one times, and last tangential to the trunk.
| Cut distance from trunk | Force reduction |
|---|---|
| 5, 4 and 3 trunk diameters | No significant reduction |
| 2 trunk diameters | 15 percent |
| 1 trunk diameter | About 23 percent |
| Tangential to the trunk | 35 percent |
Individual buttress roots
Ten trees had their buttress roots exposed with an air tool, and roots were severed one at a time, alternating sides, up to 50 percent of the root flare circumference. The trees had seven to nine buttress roots each, so one root was 11 to 14 percent of them.
- One root severed: pull force down 12 percent on average.
- Half the roots severed: down 30 percent on average, about one third in the discussion.
- One tree with 90 percent of its buttress roots on half the circumference lost more than 50 percent.
Smiley states that a general rule for the maximum share of roots that can be cut cannot be stated on this evidence. The effect of one root ranged from little to over 20 percent. He recommends against cutting any roots near the trunk and against linear trenching closer than three trunk diameters. He cautions that the study covers one species and fairly small trees, and that larger mature trees, which often lack deep roots, may be more susceptible.
New Mexico State University: critical root radius
Marisa Thompson, Extension Horticulture Specialist at NMSU, answered a reader's question on cutting roots near a sidewalk in Southwest Yard and Garden on October 25, 2003. She calls the answer uncertain: nobody can really know whether a tree will die. She describes the critical root radius as a guideline. The trunk is measured about 4.5 feet above the ground and the diameter is multiplied by 1.5 to give the radius in feet. Roots would be cut no closer than that.
Her answer says cutting farther out is better, shaving the top of a root lets disease organisms in, and a tree can still be hurt outside the radius. She suggests no more than one or two roots outside the radius in a single year and raises replacing the tree where the distance cannot be kept. She also says surface roots point to soil that is too wet or too compacted for deeper rooting.
The ISA Root Management BMP
The ISA store lists Best Management Practices: Root Management, second edition (2023, 64 pages, digital), by Laurence R. Costello, Gary Watson, E. Thomas Smiley and Richard Hauer. It replaces the 2017 first edition and is a companion to the ANSI A300 Tree Care Standards. Its topics are root systems, root inspection, root pruning and minimising conflicts with infrastructure. The store page gives no root-cutting figures.
Sources
- E. Thomas Smiley, Root Pruning and Stability of Young Willow Oak, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 34(2), March 2008, DOI 10.48044/jauf.2008.016, read October 16, 2026
- Marisa Y. Thompson, New Mexico State University Extension, Southwest Yard and Garden, Can I shave the top of tree roots?, October 25, 2003, read October 16, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, Digital BMP: Root Management, Second Edition (2023), store page, read October 16, 2026