ArbNation Join free

Sidewalk lifted by a street tree: who repairs it in five cities

New York City, Philadelphia, Portland, San Francisco and Boston each answer the question differently. San Francisco's ordinance puts sidewalk repairs tied to tree roots on the City, while Portland and Philadelphia leave it with the owner.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.

The five cities side by side

Who repairs a sidewalk lifted by a street tree root
CityWho repairs the sidewalkWhat the city says about roots and the tree
New York CityThe property owner. One-, two- or three-family homes occupied by the owner (Tax Class 1) can join the Trees & Sidewalks program, where Parks repairs sidewalks heaved by roots.Root slicing is illegal and dangerous. A Department of Transportation permit is needed before repair work.
PhiladelphiaThe property owner. The Code allows no exception for root damage.Parks & Rec looks at the tree case by case. A healthy tree is not replaced. An owner may repair a block without removing the tree if the roots are not damaged.
PortlandThe adjacent property owner.Repair usually begins with a sidewalk permit. A Root Pruning Permit from Urban Forestry may also be required.
San FranciscoThe City, for repairs related to the tree's growth or root system, since July 1, 2017.The owner keeps the rest of the sidewalk.
BostonThe Public Works Department, through a 311 sidewalk repair case.Urban Forestry can examine the roots with Public Works. It cannot remove a living, healthy street tree even if the tree affects the sidewalk.

New York City

The NYC Parks forestry FAQ puts any sidewalk repair in front of a property on the owner. Parks runs a Trees & Sidewalks program for Tax Class 1 homes, where heaving caused by tree roots is repaired. Once work is scheduled, the program is only required to repair damage caused by a City tree, so defects on a Department of Transportation violation that the tree did not cause may stay on the violation. Owners outside the program, or those who want repair before the program date, can book a Sidewalk Consultation with a Parks forester for help designing the new sidewalk.

The FAQ makes two other points. Parks does not reimburse an owner whose new sidewalk is cut away when a tree is planted. Tree pits are cut to the specifications of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Parks makes bigger pits than before to leave more room for roots and water.

Philadelphia

Philadelphia's street tree FAQ cites the Philadelphia Code: the property owner must keep a sidewalk in safe condition. When a street tree is breaking up the sidewalk, Parks & Rec inspects it and decides on the condition of the tree and its surroundings. An unhealthy tree may be listed for removal or replacement, which can take some time. An owner can remove the tree sooner with a Parks & Rec-approved contractor. The FAQ says the solution is often for the owner to replace the paving.

Portland

Portland's page on tree clearances and sidewalk problems says the adjacent property owner must repair sidewalk damage caused by street trees. City Code section 17.28.020 backs this: owners of land abutting a street are responsible for building, maintaining and repairing the sidewalks, curbs, driveways and parking strips beside their land, and are liable for injury caused by a defective sidewalk. The same section has the City maintain curbs, except curbs combined with the sidewalk that were willfully damaged or damaged by tree roots.

A Pruning Permit from Urban Forestry is required before any tree pruning in the planting strip. Sidewalks disrupted by roots are reported to the Bureau of Transportation on 503-823-1711.

San Francisco

Ordinance No. 245-17 carried out Proposition E of November 2016. From July 1, 2017, the City has the duty to maintain street trees, including trees planted earlier. Owners stay responsible for the sidewalk beside a street tree, other than sidewalk repairs related to the tree's growth or root system, which belong to the City.

The ordinance keeps one older liability: an owner can be held liable for injury or damage before July 1, 2017 caused by failing to maintain a street tree or the public right-of-way affected by its roots. A tree planted by a private owner stays outside the City's duty until it is established, which the ordinance sets at three years from planting.

Boston

Boston's Urban Forestry page says City sidewalks are maintained by the Public Works Department, and a Sidewalk Repair Case in 311 starts the process. Urban Forestry then works with Public Works to examine the roots. Public shade trees are protected by Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 87, so only the Urban Forestry Division and its contractors prune trees on City sidewalks.

Roots under sidewalks and the options for fixing them have their own page in fixing sidewalks around trees.

Who to call

Sources