ArbNation Join free

Soil drainage and percolation: how extension describes checking a planting site

Kentucky, Illinois and Maryland extension each publish a percolation check with a hole filled with water. Their hole sizes and rate thresholds differ, and the three are set side by side here.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The three extension publications are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. Kentucky's sheet ID-237 was issued in September 2016. Illinois Extension's Good Growing post is dated May 13, 2022. The University of Maryland Extension page was updated August 10, 2023.

The three checks side by side

Percolation checks as three extension publications describe them
SourceHole and pre-wettingRates it reports
Kentucky, ID-237A hole at least a foot deep, 18 inches better, 3 inches wide or more. It is filled once and drained, then refilled for the timed drain.About 2 inches per hour is ideal, and 1 to 3 is acceptable. Well under 1 is poorly drained.
Illinois ExtensionA hole at least 12 inches deep and 4 to 12 inches wide. It is filled and drained completely, which can take a short time or a whole day.1 to 3 inches per hour is desirable for most plants. Under 1 is poor drainage.
Maryland ExtensionA hole 12 inches deep and 12 inches across. It is filled, then filled again the next day.All the water should drain within eight hours. Under 1 inch per hour is too slow, and over 4 marks extremely sandy soil.

Reading the result

Kentucky's sheet measures the time the refilled hole takes to drain. It warns that digging in wet soil can glaze the hole sides, and glazed sides do not drain and give false results. Planting holes in the same landscape can drain at very different rates.

Illinois turns the reading into a rate. A ruler measures the drop in water level after 15 minutes, and the number of inches is multiplied by 4 for an hourly rate. Illinois also warns that the test gives false results when soil is overly wet.

Maryland ties a slow result to causes. A rate under 1 inch per hour may point to soil compaction, high clay content, buried debris, a high water table or a restrictive layer.

Why drainage matters

The Kentucky authors, Fountain, Durham and Crocker, report that 80 to 90 percent of disease and insect problems on landscape plants can be traced to soil problems. Too much or too little water is the most frequent reason new plants fail to establish. Saturated soils hold almost no oxygen, and plants cannot take up water there. The wilting looks like drought, which tempts more watering.

The sheet lists visual clues to poor drainage. Moss grows on the site. The soil has a sour or foul smell. Blue-gray soils hold very little oxygen, and well-drained soils are brown or reddish.

Illinois ties drainage to pore size. Sand has larger pores and drains quickly. Clay has smaller pores, slows water movement and holds it for extended periods. Compaction, from equipment as heavy as construction machinery or as light as repeated foot traffic, compresses the pores.

Drainage remedies

Kentucky lists sloped-site drains, redirecting roof and uphill water, rain gardens and raised beds. It warns that adding sand to poorly drained clay slows drainage. It also warns that large amounts of organic matter in excessively wet soil break down under low oxygen into byproducts toxic to roots. Amending the backfill in a planting hole often makes it harder for water to leave the hole.

Illinois describes compost and cover crops as ways to add organic matter, and tillage or aeration to break hardpans. Maryland sends readers with poorly drained soil to its common soil problems page. Choosing species that tolerate wet soil appears in both Kentucky and Illinois. Kentucky lists silver maple, red maple, sycamore, river birch, willow, poplar and cottonwood as floodplain species that can survive on poorly drained soils, and says such trees often have surface roots.

Sources