ArbNation Join free

Soil texture, drainage and percolation: how extension tests drainage before planting

University of Kentucky Extension puts a good planting-hole drain rate at about 2 inches an hour and calls 1 to 3 acceptable. Clemson and Colorado State describe the jar and feel tests that sort a soil into sand, silt and clay.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Drainage and texture tests are described below as University of Kentucky, Clemson and Colorado State extension services publish them. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The percolation test

Kentucky publication ID-237, Soil Percolation: A Key to Survival of Landscape Plants (Fountain, Durham and Crocker, issued September 2016), opens with a claim: 80 to 90 percent of disease and insect problems on landscape plants trace back to soil. Too much or too little water is the most frequent reason new plants fail to establish. Testing the percolation rate is the best indicator that new plants will thrive.

Percolation is water moving down through soil, and infiltration is water entering the soil. Both matter. The publication names compaction, clay, layered soils and hydrophobic mulch or surface crusting as causes of poor movement.

  1. A hole is dug with a shovel or post hole digger, at least 3 inches across and at least a foot deep, 18 inches being better. It can be as deep as the soil ball is high, and can be the planting hole itself. Digging in wet soil can glaze the sides, and glazed sides give false results.
  2. The hole is filled with water and allowed to drain.
  3. It is refilled and the time to drain is measured with a yardstick or tape.

Ideally water drains at about 2 inches an hour, and 1 to 3 inches an hour is acceptable. A rate well under 1 inch an hour marks a poorly drained site, where drainage is improved or plants that tolerate waterlogged soil are chosen. The publication adds that holes in the same landscape can drain at very different rates.

Visual clues to poor drainage

Kentucky lists colour and smell. Well-drained soils are brown or reddish. Blue-gray and white soils are almost always very poorly drained. Soil without a sweet, earthy smell, or with a sour or rotten-egg odour from organic matter breaking down without oxygen, likely drains badly. The publication also says adding sand to clay soils slows drainage, and amending backfill in planting holes often makes it harder for water to drain out. It also warns against large amounts of organic matter in poorly drained soil.

Texture classes

Colorado State Extension defines texture by particle size.

Soil particle sizes, Colorado State Extension
NameDiameter
ClayUnder 0.002 mm
Silt0.002 to 0.05 mm
Sand (very fine to very coarse)0.05 to 2.0 mm
Gravel2.0 to 75 mm

Sand feels gritty, silt smooth or floury and clay sticky. A soil with only 20 percent clay behaves as a sticky, clayey soil, while sand needs 45 to over 60 percent medium to coarse sand to behave as a sandy soil. Loam is a mix of the three, and a soil of 30 percent clay, 50 percent sand and 20 percent silt is a sandy clay loam. The USDA texture triangle and the NRCS texture calculator turn the percentages into a class name.

Texture by feel

Colorado State kneads moist soil like putty and runs three checks.

  • Ball squeeze. Sands and loamy sands break with slight pressure, sandy and silt loams hold together but change shape easily, and clayey soils resist breaking.
  • Ribbon. A ribbon under 1 inch before it breaks means sandy if gritty, or medium and high in silt if not. A ribbon of 1 to 2 inches means medium texture if gritty, or fine if not. Over 2 inches means clay.
  • Rub. A pinch rubbed between thumb and forefinger separates sandy, plain and silty forms of loam, clay loam and clay.

Texture by jar

Clemson and Colorado State both settle soil in a jar and read three layers by settling time: sand after 1 minute, silt after 2 hours, then clay. Each layer's height over the total gives the percentage. The two differ on details.

Jar test details by source
DetailClemson HGICColorado State
Soil in jarOne third fullOne quarter full, water to three quarters
PreparationSifted to remove debrisDried, cleaned, pulverised, with a teaspoon of non-foaming dishwasher detergent
ShakingUntil a uniform slurry10 to 15 minutes
Clay layer markedAfter 48 hoursWhen the water clears, usually 1 to 3 days, sometimes weeks

Sources