ArbNation Join free

Tree growth regulators in utility pruning: trial results in oak, maple and street trees

Three Arboriculture & Urban Forestry trials tested growth regulators on trees under power lines. Paclobutrazol cut regrowth in Louisiana live oak and in two maples, while a California and Nevada field program found little effect at most sites.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Tree growth regulators slow shoot growth so that trees stay clear of conductors for longer between prunings. The journal of the International Society of Arboriculture published three trials that tested them on utility trees. The trials are from 2016, 1997 and 1996, and the results differ. Label and licence terms are outside these papers. Pesticide licensing is covered in the guide to pesticide licences.

Live oak in Louisiana, 2016

Watson and Bernick studied soil-injected paclobutrazol on 48 live oaks (Quercus virginiana) along one distribution circuit in a mixed residential and commercial neighbourhood of Baton Rouge. The trees averaged 73.66 cm in trunk diameter and sat beside roads or commercial buildings. All were pruned to a clearance of 3.048 m from energized lines.

The trial tested eight timings against untreated controls: at pruning, and 30, 90 or 180 days before or after. The label rate was 1.81 g of active ingredient per cm of trunk diameter, injected 10 to 15 cm deep. Trees were re-pruned after three growing seasons.

  • Untreated trees averaged 285.8 cm of branch regrowth over three years. Treated trees averaged 187.6 cm.
  • Every timing gave shorter regrowth, pruning time and chipping time than the controls, at P below 0.05.
  • The abstract places the best timing within 90 days before to 90 days after pruning, and finds economic gains from 180 days before to 180 days after.

The paper gives the reduction in branch growth as 29.7 percent to 43.2 percent in its results and 30.0 percent to 43.2 percent in its discussion. The results contrast slightly with the ISA Utility Specialist Certification Study Guide, which targets treatment from the time of pruning to two to three months before.

Four regulators in California and Nevada, 1997

De Becker, Stubbs and Szeto report a multi-year field program at 37 sites in California and Nevada. Trees were trimmed and then treated with paclobutrazol, flurprimidol, dikegulac or uniconazole by trunk injection, tree implants or bark banding. Growth was measured as height gain over one to four years in 12 common West Coast species.

At most sites that stayed intact through the study, the regulators had no detectable effect. Growth was held back in a few cases:

  • London plane, trunk-injected with uniconazole, at one site over four years.
  • Bigleaf maple, trunk-injected with uniconazole, at one site over four years.
  • Chinese elm, trunk-injected with paclobutrazol or uniconazole, at one site over two years.
  • Blue gum, injected or banded with flurprimidol, at one site over two years.

London plane responded at only one of eight sites. The authors list site variability, tree water relations and hole spacing as possible explanations. They conclude that these regulators work under controlled conditions in greenhouses, orchards and nurseries, and that utilities use them in practice, particularly in the eastern United States. On ordinary street trees in California and Nevada, the formulations did not perform with high consistency or efficacy.

Red and silver maple, ten years on, 1996

Burch, Wells and Kline compared untreated maples with maples treated in 1984, two months after trimming. Paclobutrazol went into the soil at 0.5, 1.0 or 2.0 g of active ingredient per inch of trunk diameter. Silver maple received 300, 1,500 or 3,000 mL per tree, and red maple 1,500 mL. Untreated trees were trimmed again in 1988 and 1990. All trees were trimmed in 1994.

Biomass removed per tree in 1994 and the authors' estimated ten-year reductions
Species1994 biomassTen-year estimate
Red maple327 lb untreated, 139 lb treatedBiomass down 85 percent, trim and chip time down 76 percent
Silver maple778 lb untreated, 266 lb treatedBiomass down 88 percent, trim and chip time down 86 percent

Red maple showed no significant difference in 1994 trim and chip time, while silver maple did. At the higher application volumes there was no significant difference between the 1 g and 2 g rates. The authors write that growth regulators are not a replacement for trimming but part of an integrated approach that helps a utility keep a consistent trimming cycle.

Sources