ArbNation Join free

Trunk injection wounds: what research reports on closure, decay and repeated injections

A 2011 green ash dissection found no decay at 63 injection sites, and 76.2 percent had closed completely. A 1977 elm dissection found decay at 14 of 25 trees and severe injury where injections were repeated.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Three studies, three kinds of tree

StudyTreesMain finding
Doccola and co-authors, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 37(1), January 201114 injected green ash and 2 untreated, East Lansing, MichiganNo cracking, oozing or decay at any of 63 injection sites
Shigo and Campana, Journal of Arboriculture 3(12), December 197780 American elm, 10 to 120 cm acrossDiscolored wood at every wound; severe injury after repeated injections
Albrecht and Archer, University of Florida, slidesCitrus, 5-year-old Midsweet orange treesMost injury from high pressure with plugs; wounds heal better in June than October

Green ash: closure and decay

Doccola and co-authors felled and sectioned the trees in July 2009, 1.1 to 3.8 years after injection. The trunks were 18.8 to 36.3 cm across, and drill holes were 16 to 52 mm deep. Of the 63 injection sites, 76.2 percent were completely closed by new wound growth, 12.7 percent were closed except for a partly extruded plug, and 11.1 percent had not closed completely. Discolored areas were still visible four years after injection, but they were firm, with no sign of infection or deterioration.

Wound closure followed tree health. In the first growing season, ring growth explained 63 percent of the variation in closure. Healthy trees with under 15 percent canopy thinning closed wounds quickly. The only trees that did not recover rapidly were two heavily infested with emerald ash borer. The trees grew over more than 80 percent of the injured vascular surface within two years of injection, whatever the insecticide. Plastic ports were extruded in 13 percent of injections, with no weeping, oozing or decay. The authors observed no structural failures.

Two trees were re-injected in May 2008 with 9 mm holes against 7 mm at the first injection, and repeat sites were staggered at least 5 cm from the old ones whenever possible. The authors report the same absence of decay and structural damage in healthy green ash. They add that most injection papers cover the product's performance and rarely the injury.

American elm: decay and repeated injections

Shigo and Campana dissected 80 elms that had been injected against Dutch elm disease. Discolored wood was associated with every wound. Wounds made in several successive years caused severe internal injuries. In Delaware, Ohio, 14 of 25 trees had decay associated with three-year-old wounds: 3 of 8 trees injected through slanted holes and 11 of 17 injected through shallow holes. The amount of chemical showed no link to decay. At Maine sites, large old trees with repeated injections by gravity flow, deep holes with pressure and shallow holes with pressure had severe internal injuries, and obvious decay appeared in one case within a year.

The response varied. Trees with a small central heartwood core and one injection had very slight injury. Where wounds reached a large core or older decay, the discolored columns coalesced and grew much larger. The authors say the same treatment can injure one tree slightly and another of the same species severely. They do not discuss efficacy and do not suggest stopping injections. The 1977 trees received fungicide injections, not the insecticides in the ash study.

For cases where injections must be made, they suggest holes as small, shallow, clean-edged and few as possible. A later site would sit at least 46 cm (18 in) above older ones and not directly over them. They also suggest avoiding drilling at budbreak and in the valleys of fluted roots.

Citrus: pressure, plugs and season

Albrecht and Archer of the University of Florida Southwest Florida Research and Education Center give a slide deck on citrus trunk injection. The slides describe the compartmentalization of decay in trees (CODIT) model of Shigo and Marx, 1977, with four walls and the barrier zone as the strongest. In their field trial, injections went into 5-year-old Midsweet orange trees in October 2020 at three pressures.

The slides report the most injury from high pressure injection combined with plugs. Citrus trees effectively compartmentalized wounds from medium or low pressure injection of water. Injected compounds can be phytotoxic and inhibit compartmentalization, and syringe wounds healed better in June than October. The summary says wound healing is better in spring and that long-term effects on tree health remain to be established.

The green ash and elm studies used different species, methods, products and eras. The green ash paper itself points out that ash has broad conducting sapwood compared with elm and oak.

Sources