Two-rope working in UK arboriculture: HSE position and the industry code
HSE defines work positioning and rope access differently under the Work at Height Regulations 2005, and it will not change those definitions. The industry code of practice took the work positioning view for all rope and harness climbing.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. HSE text is adapted from HSE pages published under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
HSE's two climbing techniques
HSE states that the Work at Height Regulations 2005 do not ban climbing work. For tree work at height, employers have a duty to plan the work and select appropriate work equipment. The Regulations allow climbing with a personal fall protection system, meaning ropes and a harness, only if three conditions are met.
- A risk assessment has shown the work can be done safely using that system.
- The use of other, safer work equipment, such as a mobile elevating work platform, is not justified.
- The user and a sufficient number of available people have training specific to the task, including rescue techniques.
HSE names two main techniques and sets different wording for each.
| Technique | Examples HSE gives | HSE wording on lines and backup |
|---|---|---|
| Work positioning | Changeover climbing with a harness, friction knot and climbing line. | Where possible the system should be securely attached to two load-bearing anchor points. Each anchor point should be strong enough to support the climber, work equipment and any foreseeable loading. Work positioning systems should only be used if there is a suitable backup system for preventing or arresting a fall. If the backup system includes a second line, the user must be connected to it. |
| Rope access and positioning | Footlocking or single rope technique (SRT). | Should only be used if there are at least two separately anchored lines, one the working line and the other a safety line. The user must be connected to both lines using a suitable harness. A single rope can be used if a risk assessment has shown that a second line would entail higher risk, and appropriate safety measures have been taken. |
HSE adds that where a backup system is not reasonably practicable, the work positioning system must not fail. Its examples are training, properly chosen equipment, reliable anchor points, following industry and HSE guidance, and the correct use of tools. HSE also says it has worked with industry to clarify what is deemed reasonably practicable as to whether two climbing lines and anchors should be used. It points to the industry code of practice and the Arboricultural Association's Technical Guide 1.
The Association's account of the HSE position
The Arboricultural Association (AA) published two pages on the decision in 2019. They record that HSE had been invited to comment on the draft of Technical Guide 1, Tree Climbing and Aerial Rescue. HSE was broadly supportive but objected to how the draft defined climbing systems. The AA reports that HSE confirmed its definitions of work positioning and rope access would not change, and that its inspectors would use them in any investigation, for example after an accident.
The AA records HSE's observation that there is an assumption that a single line will suffice in most situations. Supplementary anchors may be widely used at the point of work. Most access and movement around the crown, in the AA's account of HSE's view, happens on a single line, doubled or stationary.
The AA also records what the decision does and does not change.
- For a moving rope system, the reasonably practicable test still applies. HSE inspectors would expect two points of attachment to be the norm for most of the time.
- Stationary rope technique, whether used for direct access into the tree or as a work positioning technique, is defined as rope access.
- Rope access carries the higher test in Schedule 5, Part 3 of the Regulations: a single rope only where a risk assessment shows a second line would entail higher risk and appropriate safety measures have been taken.
- HSE confirmed that during body thrusting and multiple changeovers on ascent, one point of attachment is acceptable between disconnecting and reconnecting the second line to a higher anchor.
The AA page quotes an HM Inspector of Health and Safety: "Climbing and working with a single rope has remained the custom and practice in the industry for too long and been a factor in many falls from height."
The industry code of practice
The Industry Code of Practice for Arboriculture, Tree Work at Height (ICoP), was published in 2015. The AA describes it as written for the responsible person within arboricultural contracting companies, setting out principles for managing work at height. It takes the view that all tree climbing with rope and harness can be described as work positioning. The AA says that view removes the higher Schedule 5, Part 3 test for rope access techniques.
The AA writes that HSE broadly accepted this in 2015 and later told the AA it could not support the approach. The AA states that it would revise the ICoP in light of the decision. Its decision page lists a draft ICoP for consultation dated 18 December 2019 and a consultation update dated 4 February 2020.
The AA traces earlier guidance too. The first Guide to Good Climbing Practice, in 1998, recommended supplementary anchor points and two separate lines wherever possible. The 2005 edition followed an HSE-commissioned report, Determination of rope access and work positioning techniques in arboriculture.
Accident figures in the HSE and AA accounts
The AA reports HSE's argument that arboriculture has the highest accident rate per capita of all UK industries. The AA adds that the sector has no Standard Industrial Classification code of its own, so reliable injury data is hard to keep. HSE analysed RIDDOR reports for April 2017 to March 2018 by keyword search and heavily caveated the result. It found 117 reportable incidents in arboriculture, 23 of them falls from height, one fatal.
Sources
- HSE, Tree climbing (tree work safety topics), page dated September 22, 2026, read October 19, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Background to the HSE decision on two rope working, August 15, 2019, read October 19, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, HSE Decision on Two-Rope Working, September 3, 2019, last modified February 19, 2020, read October 19, 2026