Urban soil remediation: compost incorporation, scarifying and soil profile rebuilding
A Washington State stormwater rule, a Washington State University roadside trial and a Cornell study of scoop-and-dump soil each deal with compost in compacted soil. Their figures differ, and so do their conclusions.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Three published sources deal with compacted urban soil and compost: a stormwater best management practice (BMP) as a city guide prints it, a roadside field trial and a Cornell study of deep compost incorporation. The facts below are the ones those sources publish. It is not training and does not teach the work.
Washington's soil quality and depth BMP
The Washington State Department of Ecology publishes BMP T5.13, "Post Construction Soil Quality and Depth", in its Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington. The City of Mercer Island hosts "Building Soil" (5th edition, 2018), which reproduces the BMP as revised December 2014. Ecology's manuals page lists a 2024 manual and the 2019 and 2012 editions. The 2014 wording is the text described here.
For land cleared and graded, the 2014 text calls for a topsoil layer with at least 10 percent organic matter by dry weight in planting beds and 5 percent in turf areas. The pH is to be 6.0 to 8.0 or match the undisturbed soil. The minimum depth is eight inches, except where tree roots limit how deep amendments can go. Subsoils below the topsoil should be scarified at least 4 inches, with some incorporation of the upper material to avoid stratified layers, where feasible. Planting beds get 2 inches of organic mulch. The BMP can be considered infeasible on till soil slopes greater than 33 percent.
| Option | What the guide describes |
|---|---|
| 1 | Leave native vegetation and soil undisturbed, protected from compaction and fenced off during construction. If neither soil nor vegetation is disturbed, these areas do not require amendment |
| 2 | Amend the existing topsoil or subsoil. Scarify or till the subgrade to 8 inches, or deeper to reach 12 inches of uncompacted soil. The pre-approved rate for planting beds is 3 inches of compost rototilled into 5 inches of soil, giving about 9.5 inches that settles to 8. Turf areas use 1.75 inches of compost into 6.25 inches of soil. A calculated rate is the alternative |
| 3 | Stockpile the existing topsoil during grading and replace it before planting |
| 4 | Import a topsoil mix with enough organic content and depth, for example a mix with 10 percent organic matter for planting beds |
The pre-approved rates apply only to compost meeting the bioretention compost specification (BMP T7.30), with an organic matter content of 40 to 65 percent and a carbon to nitrogen ratio below 25:1. The ratio may reach 35:1 for plantings made up entirely of Puget Sound Lowlands natives. The guide says scarifying stays out of the drip line of existing trees to be retained.
Roadside trial: surface compost against incorporated compost
Andy Bary, Rita Hummel and Craig Cogger of Washington State University, Puyallup, reported a three-year field study at the 2014 ASA, CSSA and SSSA annual meetings. The site was a heavily compacted highway roadside gravelly sand subsoil. Woody yard-debris compost and a Class A biosolids-bark blend went on 7.5 cm deep, either mixed in or left on the surface, with surface vermicompost as a further treatment. Everything was covered with 7.5 cm of bark mulch in February 2007 and planted with coralberry, fragrant sumac and Oregon grape.
Plant growth and vigor usually increased in the order control, yard-debris compost, biosolids blend, vermicompost. Incorporated treatments usually showed lower vigor and shoot growth than surface treatments, and incorporation did not change biomass. Bulk density stayed at 2.19 g per cm3 under the surface treatments, the same as the control, and fell to 0.93 g per cm3 where compost was mixed in. Soil carbon was 4 g per kg in the control and surface treatments, 44 under yard-debris compost and 57 under the biosolids blend. Roots were still confined to the amended layer after three years. Survival was 85 percent in amended treatments, and the authors note the shallow root zone could limit growth and health in the long run.
Scoop and dump at Cornell
Miles Schwartz Sax and Nina Bassuk, in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 45(4), 2019, describe scoop and dump (S&D) as working large volumes of organic matter, about 33 percent by volume, into the soil profile with a backhoe, mini-excavator or shovel. The Cornell sites got 15 cm of campus compost, then an excavator scooped to 38 to 45 cm and dropped the material back, before planting and 7.5 cm of mulch. Soil cores were taken in October 2013 at three campus beds treated between 2007 and 2012, beside untreated turf soils (30 cores of each).
Median organic matter was 8.76 percent in S&D soils and 2.51 percent in the untreated soils. Bulk density averaged 0.931 g per cm3 against 1.597. The tree trial itself ran in a greenhouse on weeping fig for fourteen weeks, then a 26-day water deficit. Roots, shoots and leaf area grew more in the remediated soil. The larger leaf area in the remediated soil caused greater transpiration on a whole-plant basis, so the extra stored water was used at a statistically equal rate. Gas exchange fell by statistically equal amounts in both soils during the water deficit. The paper describes root-limiting bulk density as texture dependent, and cites 1.45 to 1.65 g per cm3 for loam.
Where the figures differ
Washington sets organic matter and depth targets for stormwater, and the Cornell study measures tree growth. The roadside trial found incorporation did not beat surface application on vigor, though it was the only treatment that lowered bulk density. The Cornell paper is a greenhouse test of field-remediated soil, with weeping fig as the test species. The three sources do not share a protocol. For the wider decompaction literature, see the guide to what research and cities say about decompaction.
Sources
- City of Mercer Island, hosting Building Soil: Guidelines and Resources for Implementing Soil Quality and Depth BMP T5.13, 5th edition, 2018, read October 16, 2026
- Bary, Hummel and Cogger, Washington State University, Landscape plant response to surface-applied and incorporated biosolids and compost on a compacted urban subsoil, ASA, CSSA and SSSA meetings abstract, 2014, read October 16, 2026
- Sax and Bassuk, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 45(4), 2019: tree growth and gas exchange of Ficus benjamina in compacted and remediated urban soils, read October 16, 2026
- Washington State Department of Ecology, Stormwater Management Manuals index, read October 16, 2026