Which species fail most often in storms: municipal and university failure data
Three published datasets record storm failures by species: Saint Paul after two storms, Pasadena after the 2011 windstorm, and Florida after hurricanes.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The US Forest Service, the City of Pasadena's consultant and the University of Florida each counted failed trees after a named storm. Each dataset has its own method, so the figures below are not combined. They record storms only.
Saint Paul, Minnesota
A US Forest Service paper by Chad Giblin and Gary Johnson examined tree failures from two Saint Paul storms, on July 28, 2015 and July 5, 2016. Young American elms were failing from excessive canopy damage at two to three times the rate of other species in the same landscapes. The abstract cites practitioner reports that the selections 'Princeton' and 'Valley Forge' are chronically among the most damaged, which is a combination of poor structure and sheer numbers in the landscape.
Pasadena, California
Davey Resource Group analysed the November 30 to December 1, 2011 windstorm for the City of Pasadena's Department of Public Works. Official wind speeds were 60 mph, and about 5,500 reports of tree damage came in. About 2,000 total failures hit about 9 percent of the city's 57,500 trees. The analysis had limits: aggressive clean-up, no tissue, soil or trunk decay analysis, and geocoding conflicts.
Branch failures made up 56.2 percent of failures, whole tree failures 30.8 percent, major limb failures 7.2 percent and other 5.8 percent. The slides print this species table with these column headings.
| Species | Failure count | Percent of species failures | Percent of total overall population |
|---|---|---|---|
| Queensland pittosporum | 174 | 50.73% | 0.59% |
| Chinese elm | 445 | 13.65% | 5.64% |
| Indian laurel fig | 65 | 13.16% | 0.85% |
| Carrotwood | 126 | 11.39% | 1.92% |
| Western sycamore | 46 | 10.90% | 0.75% |
| Jacaranda | 166 | 10.74% | 2.76% |
| Live oak | 523 | 9.25% | 10.12% |
| Camphor tree | 295 | 5.61% | 9.19% |
| Crape myrtle | 65 | 3.28% | 3.54% |
| Mexican fan palm | 110 | 2.43% | 7.88% |
The full table has 18 species. The rows above are the seven highest and three lower ones. Live oak had the most failures by count, 523, and also the largest share of the population, 10.12 percent.
Florida hurricanes
UF/IFAS publication FR174 reports urban tree survival after hurricanes, measured within three to six days of the Florida panhandle storms. The team sampled 100 neighborhoods and 18,200 trees. Survival means the percentage of trees still standing. Trees that fell, or leaned at less than 45 degrees because of the storm, did not survive.
| Species | Survival after Ivan |
|---|---|
| Sand live oak | 99% |
| American holly | 95% |
| Southern magnolia | 92% |
| Live oak | 91% |
| Sweetgum | 86% |
| Crape myrtle | 84% |
| Laurel oak | 77% |
| Sycamore | 73% |
| Southern red oak | 60% |
| Sand pine | 48% |
| Tulip poplar | 24% |
FR174 reports that live oak survival dropped to 78 percent in Hurricanes Charley and Andrew, which struck with winds of 233 and 265 km/h. It also gives sand pine and southern red cedar as two conifers with repeatedly poor performance in the team's studies. Native trees as a group survived the same as exotic trees, 73 versus 77 percent, a difference FR174 calls not significant.
Scope of the three datasets
The Pasadena counts come from one city in one event, and the Florida figures come from neighborhood samples.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service Northern Research Station, Giblin and Johnson, Pruning cycles and storm damage: are young American elms failing prematurely? (2017, GTR NRS-P-174), read October 21, 2026
- Davey Resource Group for the City of Pasadena Department of Public Works, Pasadena Windstorm Tree Failure Analysis (slides, 2012), read October 21, 2026
- University of Florida IFAS Extension, Selecting Coastal Plain Species for Wind Resistance, FR174 (2007), read October 21, 2026