ArbNation Join free

Who pays when street tree roots lift a sidewalk: five cities and California law

Seattle, Portland, New York City, Sacramento and Los Angeles word the duty differently. Seattle and New York Parks repair root damage from City trees under programs, Portland puts it on the abutting owner, and California law sets the default.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Five cities and one state statute word differently who keeps a sidewalk in repair when street tree roots lift it.

The state default in California

California Streets and Highways Code section 5610 covers owners of lots fronting an improved public street. It also covers lots separated from the street by a park or parking strip. Those owners keep the sidewalk in a condition that does not endanger persons or property. The section carves out conditions created or maintained by another person under a permit or right granted by law or by the city authorities. That person then carries a like duty.

The Sacramento County Public Law Library reads the section as putting repair on the abutting owner even where publicly owned trees cause the damage. It adds that some cities take on part or all of the cost, particularly for damage from city trees.

Five cities

Sidewalk repair duty and tree ownership, as each city's pages and code word them
CityWhat the official text prints
SeattleDuty: The Municipal Code requires adjacent owners to keep sidewalks in good repair, including repairs when damaged. A permit comes before repair, and an SDOT Arborist evaluates before roots over 2 inches in diameter are pruned.
City trees: If City infrastructure such as a City-owned tree or sewer line causes the damage, the City takes responsibility for repairs. Street trees planted by the City are usually maintained by SDOT or the Parks Department. Street trees planted by citizens are the abutting owner's to maintain to City standards.
Program: The Sidewalk Repair Program, funded by the Levy to Move Seattle, considers a damaged sidewalk only if it is next to City-owned property or City-owned trees are causing the damage. The City reports a significant backlog.
PortlandDuty: Code 17.28.020 A makes owners of abutting land responsible for building, rebuilding, maintaining and repairing sidewalks, curbs, driveways and parking strips. Owners are liable for damages to a person hurt by a defective sidewalk, and to the City for amounts it pays out on claims.
Roots: Subsection B has the City maintain curbs, except curbs combined with the sidewalk that were willfully damaged or damaged by tree roots. The tree page puts street tree sidewalk damage on the adjacent owner, as it does maintenance of trees in the planting strip.
New York CityProgram: The NYC Parks Trees & Sidewalks Program can repair severe root damage next to owner-occupied one-, two- and three-family homes (Tax Class 1) not used commercially. Funding is limited. Each inspected site gets a rating from 1 to 100: under 80 is not repaired, 80 to 90 is waitlisted, and 90 and over is expected to be repaired within three years.
Own repair: An owner may hire a contractor under a Tree Work Permit and a DOT sidewalk permit, then file a claim with the Comptroller within 90 days of repair for damage believed caused by a City tree.
Violations: NYC DOT is no longer issuing violations or liens to owners of owner-occupied one- to three-family homes where only City trees cause the damage.
SacramentoPer the Law Library, Sacramento City Code 12.32.020 puts the entire repair cost on the property owner, whatever the cause of the damage.
Los AngelesThe City's Sidewalks program, launched in December 2016 as a 30-year, US$1.4 billion effort to make sidewalks accessible, runs a Sidewalk Rebate Program that reimburses eligible property owners for part of the cost of their sidewalk repair. Its rebates page reports delays from new funding restrictions, with all new applications placed on a waitlist.

Where the cities differ

Seattle and New York make the City the repairer when its own tree is the cause, each through a program with limits on which sites qualify. Portland's code and tree page keep the duty with the owner, with the City keeping only curbs that tree roots have not damaged. Sacramento's code, as the Law Library reads it, makes no exception for the cause.

The Law Library gives the reasoning behind the California default: owners get the aesthetics, cooling and added property value of City trees, so the sidewalk cost falls to them. The section dates to a 1935 measure. The Library notes that most states and major cities have similar laws.

Sources