ArbNation Join free

Pervious and flexible pavement around trees: what research reports on roots and survival

Field trials of porous and permeable paving around young trees report more soil water and, in one trial, more growth. A second trial found roots under porous and solid pavement spread in similar ways.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Porous pavements pass air and water through to the soil. Researchers have asked two questions about them near trees: do the trees grow and survive better, and do the roots stay out of the paving? Four publications give the answers below, each as its authors report it. Most of the trials used young trees, so none reports on mature street trees.

Paving in the review of root conflicts

Randrup, McPherson and Costello reviewed the literature on tree root conflicts with sidewalks, curbs and roads. It appeared in Urban Ecosystems in 2003 and is held by the U.S. Forest Service's Pacific Southwest Research Station. It names these factors as raising the chance of conflict:

  • Tree species that are large at maturity, and fast-growing trees.
  • Restricted soil volume and shallow topsoil.
  • Shallow foundations under the sidewalk, with little or no base material.
  • Shallow irrigation.
  • Trees within 2.0 to 3.0 m of the sidewalk, and trees over 15 to 20 years old.

On surface material, the review cites Wong and colleagues (1988), who found more root conflicts with asphalt sidewalks than with concrete ones. It also reports a finding by Sydnor and colleagues (2000): in 3 of 4 soil complexes sampled, sidewalk blocks of all ages were more likely to be raised where there were no trees than where trees stood.

The review has a short section on porous surface layers. It lists porous asphalt, porous concrete and paving blocks with open joints or drainage holes. The authors reason that such layers might limit condensation and lower the temperature under a slab, which could reduce rooting at the soil interface. They might also cost less to repair. More research is needed to determine the net effect of porous surfaces on root growth.

Oriental plane trials

Justin Morgenroth, with Rien Visser on the first, published two linked papers in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 2011. Both used fifty oriental plane (Platanus orientalis) seedlings. They were spread over control plots and four treatments of porous or impervious pavement pads measuring 2.3 m by 2.3 m. The pads sat over either fine sandy loam or a gravel base on compacted subgrade.

PaperReported result
Aboveground growth (January 2011)Stem height, diameter and biomass increased as a result of porous pavements. That gain was cancelled by profiles with a compacted subgrade and gravel base. Impervious pavements did not reduce growth against control trees
Root growth (March 2011)After two growing seasons, root abundance was greater under pavements, especially at shallow depths. A compacted subgrade and gravel base made shallow rooting worse. Porous and impervious pavements affected root abundance and distribution in similar ways

The author of the second paper says the results dismiss the use of porous pavements to promote deeper rooting. The first paper says the findings may not carry over to other climates, species, soils or pavement widths, and that sidewalks, roads and plazas need testing.

An eight-year Italian trial

Fini, Frangi, Vigevani, Comin and Ferrini of the University of Milan presented a trial begun in 2011 at the International Society of Arboriculture's annual conference, held online in 2020. Forty-eight trees of two species, Fraxinus ornus and Celtis australis, were each planted in a 1 m2 pit. Around each pit lay 50 m2 (538 sq ft) of one of four surfaces: asphalt on concrete sub-base, pavers on crushed rock, monolithic porous pavement on crushed rock, or bare soil kept clear of weeds.

The abstract reports:

  • While trees were getting established, permeable and porous pavements can increase soil water availability and improve tree health compared with the control.
  • Young trees beside asphalt did not benefit from the extra moisture. The authors suggest root activity was probably hindered by higher soil CO2.
  • Once established, trees used more water, and soil moisture fell, most under impervious pavements. It stayed above the wilting point in every treatment.
  • Health of established trees was only slightly affected by the pavements, even though soil conditions differed greatly.
  • Celtis australis developed larger leaf areas than Fraxinus ornus and adapted to all pavement types.

Root distribution was to be assessed with georadar and tomography between December 2019 and March 2020. The abstract does not give those results.

Related pages cover paving near tree roots and tree roots and sidewalks.

Sources